Enhancing Human Development Assessment through Multi-Criteria Decision Making: A Case Study of Health Status and Services in West Azerbaijan, Iran

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 M.Sc., Department of Industrial Engineering, Urmia University, Urmia, Iran.

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Industrial Engineering, Sharif University of Technology, Tehran, Iran.

3 Professor, Department of Industrial Engineering, Urmia University, Urmia, Iran.

Abstract

This study investigates the Human Development Index (HDI), a composite measure developed by the United Nations Development Program to evaluate human development through life expectancy, education, and income. This research aims to assess the health status and services across 17 cities in West Azerbaijan Province, Iran, using multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) techniques: TOPSIS, MOORA, ARAS, and COPRAS. Eight health indicators, including primary medical care centers, laboratories, active beds, pharmacies, general practitioners, specialists, subspecialists, and dentists, were used for the ranking. The Shannon entropy method was applied to determine the weights of these indicators. The results reveal significant disparities in health service distribution, with Urmia, Khoy, and Miandoab having the best health services, while Poldasht, Chaldoran, and Chaypareh are the most deprived. The study employs the Spearman rank correlation coefficient to validate the rankings and utilizes the utility interval aggregation method to enhance reliability. Managerial insights suggest that policymakers should prioritize equitable distribution of health services to mitigate disparities and promote balanced regional development. Effective resource allocation and targeted interventions in underserved areas are crucial for improving overall human development.

Keywords

Main Subjects


Abolhallaje, M., Mousavi, S. M., Anjomshoa, M., Nasiri, A. B., Seyedin, H., Sadeghifar, J., ... & Nasiri, M. B. (2014). Assessing health inequalities in Iran: a focus on the distribution of health care facilities. Global journal of health science6(4), 285.
Akinlo, A. E., & Sulola, A. O. (2019). Health care expenditure and infant mortality in sub-Saharan Africa. Journal of Policy Modeling41(1), 168-178.
Ameye, H., & Swinnen, J. (2019). Obesity, income and gender: the changing global relationship. Global Food Security23, 267-281.
Anele, C. R., Hirakata, V. N., Goldani, M. Z., & da Silva, C. H. (2021). The influence of the municipal human development index and maternal education on infant mortality: an investigation in a retrospective cohort study in the extreme south of Brazil. BMC Public Health21, 1-12.
Anjomshoa, M., Mousavi, S. M., Seyedin, H., Ariankhesal, A., Sadeghifar, J., & Shaarbafchi-Zadeh, N. (2013). Evidence for policy making: health services access and regional disparities in kerman.
Araujo, C. A. S., Wanke, P., & Siqueira, M. M. (2018). A performance analysis of Brazilian public health: TOPSIS and neural networks application. International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management67(9), 1526-1549.
Ataey, A., Jafarvand, E., Adham, D., & Moradi-Asl, E. (2020). The relationship between obesity, overweight, and the human development index in world health organization eastern mediterranean region countries. Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health53(2), 98.
Bahadori, M., Shams, L., Sadeghifar, J., Hamouzadeh, P., & Nejati, M. (2012). Classification of health structural indicators using scalogram model in golestan province, northern iran. Iranian journal of public health41(5), 58.
Banerjee, S., & Mukherjee, P. (2022). Eco-Environment Friendly Cost-Effective Synthesis for Sustainable Human Development in Context of Globalization. In Globalization, Income Distribution and Sustainable Development: A Theoretical and Empirical Investigation (pp. 235-250). Emerald Publishing Limited.
Bhattacharya, R., Raut, R. D., Gardas, B. B., & Kamble, S. S. (2020). Sustainable partner selection: an integrated AHP-TOPSIS approach. International Journal of Operational Research39(2), 205-236.
Brauers, W. K., & Zavadskas, E. K. (2006). The MOORA method and its application to privatization in a transition economy. Control and cybernetics35(2), 445-469.
Brauers, W. K. M., Zavadskas, E. K., Peldschus, F., & Turskis, Z. (2008). Multi‐objective decision‐making for road design. Transport23(3), 183-193.
Chakraborty, S. (2011). Applications of the MOORA method for decision making in manufacturing environment. The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology54, 1155-1166.
Chou, C. Y., Shen, T. T., Wang, W. C., & Wu, M. P. (2024). Favorable breast cancer mortality-to-incidence ratios of countries with good human development index rankings and high health expenditures. Taiwanese Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology63(4), 527-531.
da Silva, B. E. B., de Lemos, L. M. D., Moura, A. R., Ferrari, Y. A. C., Lima, M. S., de Oliveira Santos, M., & Lima, C. A. (2024). Gynaecological cancer incidence and mortality trends in a Brazilian State with medium human development index: A 22-year analysis. Cancer Epidemiology88, 102493.
Dearie, C., Linhart, C., Rafai, E., Nand, D., Morrell, S., & Taylor, R. (2021). Trends in mortality and life expectancy in Fiji over 20 years. BMC public health21, 1-14.
Figueiredo, V., Bayer, S., & Junior, I. F. (2022). Infant mortality in a Brazilian municipality with a high human development index. Turkish Archives of Pediatrics57(6), 630.
Goker, N., Karsak, E. E., & Dursun, M. (2022). An integrated QFD and common weight DEA-based fuzzy MCDM framework for performance ranking of countries. Social Indicators Research, 1-22.
Hassanipour-Azgomi, S., Mohammadian-Hafshejani, A., Ghoncheh, M., Towhidi, F., Jamehshorani, S., & Salehiniya, H. (2016). Incidence and mortality of prostate cancer and their relationship with the Human Development Index worldwide. Prostate international4(3), 118-124.
Hirai, T., & Hirai, T. (2017). History of development: towards human development. The Creation of the Human Development Approach, 1-20.
Human Development Report. (2023).
Hwang, C. L., Yoon, K., Hwang, C. L., & Yoon, K. (1981). Methods for multiple attribute decision making. Multiple attribute decision making: methods and applications a state-of-the-art survey, 58-191.
Investopedia. (2024). What is the Human Development Index (HDI)?
Khazaei, Z., Ghorat, F., Jarrahi, A. M., Adineh, H. A., Sohrabivafa, M., & Goodarzi, E. J. W. C. R. J. (2019). Global incidence and mortality of skin cancer by histological subtype and its relationship with the human development index (HDI); an ecology study in 2018. World Cancer Res J6(2), e13.
Kovacevic, M., Assa, J., Bonini, A., Calderon, C., Hsu, Y. C., Lengfelder, C., & Tapia, H. (2018). Human Development Indicators and Indices: 2018 Statistical Update. United Nations.
Land, K. C. (2015). The human development index: objective approaches (2). Global handbook of quality of life: Exploration of well-being of nations and continents, 133-157.
Limpianchob, C., Sasabe, M., & Kasahara, S. (2022). A multi-objective optimisation model for production and transportation planning in a marine shrimp farming supply chain network. International Journal of Operational Research45(1), 1-28.
Mohammadian-Hafshejani, A., Farber, I. M., & Kheiri, S. (2024). Global incidence and mortality of childhood leukemia and its relationship with the Human Development Index. Plos one19(7), e0304354
Mahboubi, M., Rastegarimehr, B., Sajedinejad, M., Zahedi, A., Baeradeh, N., Rezaei, L., & Ebrazeh, A. (2020). The Developmental Status of Abadan, Khorramshahr and Shadegan Terms of Health Indices Using Numerical Taxonomy Model. Journal of Research Development in Nursing and Midwifery17(2), 1-3.
Mansori, K., Khazaei, S., Khosravi Shadmani, F., Mansouri Hanis, S., Jenabi, E., Soheylizad, M., ... & Ayubi, E. (2018). Global inequalities in cervical cancer incidence and mortality. Middle East Journal of Cancer9(3), 235-242.
Mejia-Pailles, G., Berrington, A., McGrath, N., & Hosegood, V. (2020). Trends in the prevalence and incidence of orphanhood in children and adolescents< 20 years in rural KwaZulu-Natal South Africa, 2000-2014. PloS one15(11), e0238563.
Omrani, H., Alizadeh, A., & Amini, M. (2020). A new approach based on BWM and MULTIMOORA methods for calculating semi-human development index: An application for provinces of Iran. Socio-Economic Planning Sciences70, 100689.
Pathan, A. I., Agnihotri, P. G., & Patel, D. (2022). Integrated approach of AHP and TOPSIS (MCDM) techniques with GIS for dam site suitability mapping: a case study of Navsari City, Gujarat, India. Environmental Earth Sciences81(18), 443.
Qin, X., Godil, D. I., Khan, M. K., Sarwat, S., Alam, S., & Janjua, L. (2021). Investigating the effects of COVID-19 and public health expenditure on global supply chain operations: an empirical study. Operations Management Research, 1-13.
Raleigh, V. S. (2019). Trends in life expectancy in EU and other OECD countries: Why are improvements slowing?.
Reuter-Oppermann, M., Rachuba, S., & Raith, A. (2019). Multi-criteria decision making in health care. Operations research for health care23, 100234.
Sayari, M., Haghighi, M. R. R., Lankarani, K. B., Ghahramani, S., & Honarvar, B. (2022). Road Traffic Death Rate and Human Development Index in 2007-2016 at the Global Level: Trend Analysis.
Shetaban, S., Seyyed Esfahani, M. M., Saghaei, A., & Ahmadi, A. (2020). Operations research and health systems: a literature review. Journal of Industrial Engineering and Management Studies7(2), 240-260.
Silva, D. R. M. E., OLIVEIRA, M. M. D., Fernandes, G. A., & Curado, M. P. (2023). Pancreatic cancer mortality trends and correlation with human development index (HDI) in Brazil over 40 years. Arquivos de Gastroenterologia60(1), 30-38.
Statistical Center of Iran. (2019). Economic Indicators Report. Retrieved November 27, 2024, from https://amar.org.ir/Portals/0/PropertyAgent/6200/Files/98-04-18.pdf
Taherdoost, H., & Madanchian, M. (2023). Multi-criteria decision making (MCDM) methods and concepts. Encyclopedia3(1), 77-87.
Tunsi, W., & Alidrisi, H. (2023). The innovation-based human development index using Promethee II: The context of G8 Countries. Sustainability15(14), 11373.
Turskis, Z., & Zavadskas, E. K. (2010). A new fuzzy additive ratio assessment method (ARAS‐F). Case study: The analysis of fuzzy multiple criteria in order to select the logistic centers location. Transport25(4), 423-432.
Uguccioni, J. (2016). The Human Development Index in Canada: Ranking the Provinces and Territories Internationally, 2000-2014 (No. 2016-14). Ottawa, Canada: Centre for the Study of Living Standards.
UNDP. (2023). Human Development Index.
Varmazyar, M., Dehghanbaghi, M., & Afkhami, M. (2016). A novel hybrid MCDM model for performance evaluation of research and technology organizations based on BSC approach. Evaluation and program planning58, 125-140.
Voukelatou, V., Gabrielli, L., Miliou, I., Cresci, S., Sharma, R., Tesconi, M., & Pappalardo, L. (2021). Measuring objective and subjective well-being: dimensions and data sources. International Journal of Data Science and Analytics11, 279-309.
Wan, E. Y. F., Yu, E. Y. T., Chin, W. Y., Fong, D. Y. T., Choi, E. P. H., Tang, E. H. M., & Lam, C. L. K. (2019). Burden of CKD and cardiovascular disease on life expectancy and health service utilization: a cohort study of Hong Kong Chinese hypertensive patients. Journal of the American Society of Nephrology30(10), 1991-1999.
Yazdani, M., Torkayesh, A. E., Santibanez-Gonzalez, E. D., & Otaghsara, S. K. (2020). Evaluation of renewable energy resources using integrated Shannon Entropy—EDAS model. Sustainable Operations and Computers1, 35-42.
Zamani, K., & Omrani, H. (2022). A complete information PCA-imprecise DEA approach for constructing composite indicator with interval data: an application for finding development degree of cities. International Journal of Operational Research44(4), 522-549.
Zavadskas, E. K., & Turskis, Z. (2010). A new additive ratio assessment (ARAS) method in multicriteria decision‐making. Technological and economic development of economy16(2), 159-172.
Zavadskas, E., & Kaklauskas, A. (2002). Determination of an efficient contractor by using the new method of multicriteria assessment. In The organization and management of construction (pp. 94-104). Routledge.
Zhu, K. F., Wang, Y. M., Zhu, J. Z., Zhou, Q. Y., & Wang, N. F. (2016). National prevalence of coronary heart disease and its relationship with human development index: a systematic review. European journal of preventive cardiology23(5), 530-543.